Westerville, OH Local Market Overview (Oct 2026)
Whether you are liquidating broken 14k gold chains, inherited estate rings, 22k/24k gold bullion coins, or GIA-graded loose diamonds in Westerville, Ohio, payout percentages vary dramatically between street-level pawn brokers and established fine jewelers along S State St, N State St, 6295 Maxtown Rd, W Schrock Rd. Across our directory's 11 verified showrooms in Westerville (285 combined client reviews, 4.5★ average), reputable local jewelers typically pay 75% to 85% of live LBMA melt value for karat scrap gold and up to 90%–95% for hallmarked 24k bullion.
For weekend appraisals and immediate cash settlements in Westerville, 8 local showrooms operate on Saturdays and 2 open on Sundays. Leading local buyers include Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry, Allen's Coin Shop, Columbus Gold & Diamond Exchange. Always weigh your items in grams at home first and compare at least two written verbal quotes before signing a bill of sale.
Verified Showrooms in Westerville, OH
#1 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.8 (17 reviews)
BU
📍 564 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry is an esteemed jewelry showroom and custom design studio in Westerville. Offering fine handcrafted jewelry, diamond collections, and master artisan craftsmanship.
Fine JewelryCustom Consultation
#2 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.7 (26 reviews)
AL
📍 399 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Allen's Coin Shop: Your Premier Jewelry Destination in Westerville Welcome to Allen's Coin Shop , located at 399 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA . A true treasure trove for collectors and jewelry enthusiasts alike, our family-owned business has been a cornerstone of the community for over 50 years. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, Allen's Coin Shop offers a curated selection that caters to everyone’s tastes and needs.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisals
#3 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.5 (8 reviews)
CO
📍 1001 Eastwind Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Exquisite Jewelry at Columbus Gold & Diamond Exchange Welcome to Columbus Gold & Diamond Exchange , your premier destination for luxury jewelry in the heart of Westerville, Ohio . Nestled at 1001 Eastwind Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA , this stunning jewelery store is a treasure trove for every jewelry lover. With an impressive selection of high-quality pieces, you’re sure to find something that speaks to your style and budget.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisals
#4 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.7 (53 reviews)
JE
📍 6295 Maxtown Rd, Westerville, OH 43082, USA
Jewelry By Michael is an esteemed jewelry showroom and custom design studio in Westerville. Offering fine handcrafted jewelry, diamond collections, and master artisan craftsmanship.
Fine JewelryCustom Consultation
#5 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.6 (49 reviews)
GO
📍 592 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Gold Star Jewelers in Westerville, OH Welcome to Gold Star Jewelers , your premier destination for exquisite jewelry in the heart of Westerville, Ohio . Nestled at 592 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, USA , this family-owned business has been a cherished part of the community for years, renowned for its exceptional customer service and high-quality products. Whether you're searching for the perfect engagement ring, a stunning necklace, or a unique gift, Gold Star Jewelers has something special for everyone.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisalsWatch Repair
#6 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.2 (49 reviews)
MO
📍 31 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Morgan's Treasure is an esteemed jewelry showroom and custom design studio in Westerville. Offering fine handcrafted jewelry, diamond collections, and master artisan craftsmanship.
Fine JewelryCustom Consultation
#7 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.4 (22 reviews)
WE
📍 10 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Westerville Jewelers is an esteemed jewelry showroom and custom design studio in Westerville. Offering fine handcrafted jewelry, diamond collections, and master artisan craftsmanship.
Fine JewelryCustom Consultation
#8 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.5 (10 reviews)
SA
📍 221 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Elegance at Salina Austin in Westerville Welcome to Salina Austin , your premier destination for exquisite jewelry in the heart of Westerville, Ohio. Located at 221 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA , this boutique-style shop is where charm meets sophistication, offering a captivating selection of jewelry that caters to every taste and budget. ✨ At Salina Austin, we pride ourselves on our stunning collection of fine jewelry.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisals
#9 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.7 (23 reviews)
DJ
📍 708 Autumn Tree Pl, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Welcome to DJ's Just Jewelry - Your Premier Jewelry Destination in Columbus, Ohio Discover the exquisite world of jewelry at DJ's Just Jewelry , located conveniently at 708 Autumn Tree Pl, Westerville, OH 43081, USA . This stunning jewelry store is a must-visit for anyone in Columbus, Ohio, seeking that perfect piece to celebrate life's special moments. From dazzling engagement rings to unique necklaces and elegant earrings, DJ's Just Jewelry offers an unparalleled selection that caters to every taste and occasion.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisals
#10 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.5 (9 reviews)
ST
📍 22 Westerview Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Elegance at Stern Jewelers in Westerville, OH Welcome to Stern Jewelers , your ultimate destination for exquisite jewelry in the heart of Westerville, Ohio . Nestled at 22 Westerview Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA , our store is a treasure trove for jewelry enthusiasts, showcasing a stunning array of pieces that cater to every taste and occasion. Whether you’re searching for a breathtaking engagement ring or a chic pair of earrings, Stern Jewelers has something special waiting for you.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisalsCleaning & Polishing
#11 Verified Westerville Specialist
⭐ 4.3 (19 reviews)
BO
📍 8273 Market Exchange Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA
Discover Body Jewel: Your Premier Jewelry Destination in Westerville, OH Welcome to Body Jewel , located at 8273 Market Exchange Dr, Westerville, OH 43081, USA . This exquisite jewelry store is a hidden gem in Westerville, offering a stunning array of jewelry pieces that cater to every taste and occasion. Whether you’re shopping for a loved one or indulging yourself, Body Jewel has something special waiting for you.
Custom DesignJewelry RepairsAppraisals